When McKinsey partners Carolyn Dewar, Scott Keller, and Vikram Malhotra set out to understand what makes certain CEOs exceptional, they didn't rely on gut instinct or anecdotes. They analyzed data on 7,800 CEOs and conducted in-depth interviews with 67 of the best-performing leaders in the world. The result is CEO Excellence, a book that should be required reading for anyone in a leadership role.
The Premise: It's About Mindsets, Not Tactics
Here's what struck me most: the differentiator isn't what excellent CEOs do, it's how they think about what they do. Two CEOs can make the same strategic decision, but the one with the right mindset will execute it in a way that creates dramatically different outcomes.
The authors identify six key responsibilities every CEO faces, and within each, they reveal the mindset shifts that separate the excellent from the average.
The Six Responsibilities (And Their Mindsets)
1. Setting Direction: Be Bold
Average CEOs set incremental goals. Excellent CEOs reframe the game entirely. They ask, "What would it take to be in the top quartile of our industry?" rather than "How can we improve 5% this year?"
"The best CEOs don't just set ambitious targets, they fundamentally reimagine what's possible for their organization."
2. Aligning the Organization: Treat the Soft Stuff as the Hard Stuff
Culture isn't a fluffy HR initiative, it's a strategic weapon. Excellent CEOs obsess over organizational health with the same rigor they apply to financial metrics. They know that a toxic culture will eat any strategy for breakfast.
3. Mobilizing Through Leaders: Solve for the Team's Psychology
This one hit home for me. The best CEOs don't just build executive teams with complementary skills, they actively manage the team's dynamics, ensuring healthy debate without destructive conflict. They're part coach, part therapist, part orchestra conductor.
4. Engaging the Board: Help Directors Help the Business
Instead of viewing the board as an obstacle or rubber stamp, excellent CEOs treat directors as strategic assets. They share real challenges, invite genuine debate, and leverage the board's diverse experience.
5. Connecting with Stakeholders: Start with "Why?"
In an era of stakeholder capitalism, the best CEOs don't just manage shareholders, they build genuine relationships with employees, customers, communities, and regulators. They articulate a purpose that resonates beyond profit.
6. Managing Personal Effectiveness: Do What Only You Can Do
This might be the most actionable chapter. Excellent CEOs ruthlessly protect their time for the activities that only the CEO can do, and delegate everything else. They also invest heavily in their own recovery and reflection.
My Key Takeaways
After reading this book twice (yes, twice), here's what I'm applying to my own work:
- Vision needs to be visceral. A 10% improvement doesn't inspire anyone. Reframe challenges as "how do we become the absolute best?"
- Culture is a leading indicator. By the time cultural problems show up in financial results, you're already in trouble. Measure organizational health proactively.
- Time is the CEO's scarcest resource. Every hour spent on something a direct report could handle is an hour stolen from strategic work.
- Boards are underutilized assets. Most leaders treat board meetings as performances. The best treat them as working sessions.
Key Takeaway
The differentiator is not what excellent CEOs do, it is how they think about what they do. Two leaders can make the same decision, but the one with the right mindset will produce dramatically different outcomes.
Who Should Read This
Obviously, current and aspiring CEOs will find this invaluable. But I'd also recommend it for:
- Fractional executives who need to create impact quickly
- Board members who want to be better partners to management
- Anyone building or scaling a company
- Leadership coaches and consultants
The Bottom Line
CEO Excellence is one of the most research-backed, actionable leadership books I've read. Unlike many business books that could be blog posts, this one earns its 400+ pages. Each chapter includes specific practices, real examples, and honest discussions of trade-offs.
The core message is both humbling and empowering: excellence isn't about having superhuman abilities, it's about consistently applying the right mindsets to the right responsibilities.
Rating: 9/10
A must-read for anyone serious about executive leadership. Dense but practical, research-backed but readable.
Share this article:
